Are You a Chrismatic or a Charismatic?

They went out from us, but they were not of us: for if they had been of us, they would no doubt have continued with us, but they went out, that they might be made manifest that they were not all of us. But ye have an unction from the Holy One, and ye know all things. – 1 John 2:19,20

Readers of The Cambrian Peshers, especially the ones having to do with St. Ignatius of Antioch, will readily understand the difference between a Chrismatic and a Charismatic.

We recently passed his natal day (October 17th) in the Church’s hagiography. Beloved by the Catholic and Orthodox, despised by the Protestants, he is misunderstood by them all. It is over the role of the bishop and his plenary authority in the local church that is at controversy. The Establishment churches adore him because he demanded obedience “as unto Christ.” The Protestants regard him as a myth and his doctrine as a later innovation.

The word “Charismatic,” derived from “Charis”, obviously refers to the current spiritual movement associated with Pentecostals, spiritualists, and other mystic groups and denominations which emphasize the baptism of the Holy Spirit, the gifts (charis) of the Spirit, and the kind of enthusiastic worship practices that have a heavy emphasis on modern-style music and stage performance.  Awareness of these people has seeped into the general culture and I need not belabor the point here.

“Chrismatic,” however, comes from “chrism” and occurs only three times in the New Testament, in our opening text above and here:

These things have I written unto you concerning them that seduce you. But the anointing which ye have received of him abideth in you and ye need not that any man teach you: but as the same anointing teacheth you of all things, and is truth, and is no lie, and even as it hath taught you, ye shall abide in him. 1 John 2:26-27

Found only in this first epistle of “John,“ it is something obviously unique to the Johannine Community.  These people had received what is translated here as an “unction” or “anointing.” What it might have been deserves a closer analysis.

The old churches, of course, surmise that it has something to do with the baptism or indwelling of the Holy Spirit and early on devised ceremonies called “holy unction” for healing, and also the rite of chrism which is sometimes conflated with water baptism. Modern Charismatics hijack the word to refer to a spiritual power in their ecstatic utterances and peculiar prophetic dispositions. They claim not to need the Bible or to be taught because the “author” of inspiration dwells within them. When they speak, they speak a “living” word. They confuse “chrism” with “charis.”

However, chrism is not something having anything to do with the baptism of the Holy Spirit, nor with any spiritual gift but rather with a birth ritual practiced by midwives to identify an heir.  It referred to the rubbing of an unguent into the skin of a recently born child to ward off evil spirits, to afford physical protection to the infant’s delicate skin, and also to create a newborn scent unique to the respective family.  A smell test was a way of authenticating and differentiating it from others. Baby swapping was a problem in the ancient world just as it is sometimes scandalously done today. The smell test served as a way of authenticating and differentiating the royal newborn child from others: hence a purpose for the “frankincense and myrrh” of the Magi.

If you read the previous verses prior to our opening text above, the word “they” refers to the “many antichrists” identified in verse 18. These “antichrists” or anti-messiahs or anti-anointed ones – they did not have the witness of this “unguent” and consequently, left the fellowship. They were not of the messianic tribe.

During the 1st Century AD, in the years prior to Christ’s ministry and after until the Bar Kochba rebellion in 134 AD, there were no less than a dozen messianic claimants known to history. Some claimed to be of the lineage of King David. Even Herod the Great had messianic claims. They may or may not have been “of the blood” but none of them had the “unction” which Jesus alone received at his baptism (the dove from heaven).

However, a “pseudo” Christ was not the same as an “anti” Christ. Amidst this chaos, even among the covenant community of the Jesus movement, to combat the many fraudulent messianic aspirants, church leaders began to distance themselves from the messianic office. They sought to replace the Messianic character of the bishops of the church with an apostolic one. Hence, they became “anti” Christs.

For the recipients of this Johannine epistle, what guarded them from these rivals was the knowledge that they possessed the “unguent,” the anointing which marked them as belonging to the household of Jesus Christ. He was and remained the only true Messiah. The apostolic doctrine sought to replace the messianic doctrine of “the father and the son” and showed itself to be “Antichrist” (1 John 2:22).

We have provided sufficient research to show that what is called the Johannine Community by scholars was really the Bethany Family as an extension of the very family of Jesus Christ. Midwives were important to the process of a birth “certification” in forming what church leaders later described as “the Desposyni.”

The Johannine Community felt differently about the notion of apostolic succession. Ignatius taught a “Desposynic” episcopacy because it represented a continuation of David’s line. David’s descendants were given the bishop’s throne to rule as monarchs in the first century of the Church’s existence.  We believe that the Epistles of John were specifically addressed to Ignatius and his mother, Martha, who at the time of composition, lived in Cyprus. Ignatius claimed a Davidic origin to the Messianic office in Jesus Christ and demanded that His successors exercise a monarchical episcopacy. Emboldened by the Epistle’s charge cited above: “You have need of no man to teach you . . .” Ignatius could rely upon his position as Christ’s direct heir and successor in refuting the “synagogue of Satan.” The later Catholic and Orthodox would misappropriate that authority to themselves and become a rival episcopacy.

Consequently, “Chrismatic” is not a reference to a spiritual power or a sacerdotal ritual. It is simply a reference to the birthright of the descendants of Jesus Christ:

The sacraments of the church are optional with such people – as Christ upbraided John the Baptist, “Suffer it to be so, thus to fulfill all righteousness” – but rather are enjoined to be observed for their pedagogical value, not a soteriological one.

Such people do not need to be baptized with the Holy Spirit because they are born with the Holy Spirit from their mother’s womb.

It has taken us decades to research and test this doctrine.  The last twenty five years have been spent elucidating it. We expect that it will become common knowledge in the 2030s, the decade leading up to the Great Eschaton.

For a deep dive, go here: https://2046ad.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/BM3.pdf

— JWS, 11/15/26

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *